I have a lot of already existing web applications that are not in Drupal. They are independent systems. I am looking to create an Intranet solution to tie them all together, meaning, have links to them, not an integration with Drupal.

Is this using Drupal as a CMS or a Portal? Does this go against the philosophy of what Drupal is for? I want to use Drupal 8 if it matters.

  • From the way you're describing it Drupal would be overkill for what you're doing.
    – user5482
    Aug 31, 2015 at 15:57
  • @user5482 so you think it would be something with just a flat HTML setup?
    – johnny
    Aug 31, 2015 at 16:08

1 Answer 1


Is this using Drupal as a CMS or a Portal?

I would say "CMS", and probably even "CMF" (Content Management Framework). E.g. using things such as Webservices.

Does this go against the philosophy of what Drupal is for?

No, it's just 1 out of dozens of usages of Drupal.

I want to use Drupal 8 if it matters.

Depends how much in a hurry you are, but I'd strongly recommend to not yet use D8 in production. Some more details on that:

  • Use Drupal 7 if you want to build production ready sites today, or in the near future.
  • Use Drupal 8 to get ready for "the future". To answer the (next) predictable question (= by when would I have to be ready for that), be aware of the famous quote from "Mr. Dries", which is something like: Drupal 8 will be ready when it's ready ....

Some more words/thoughts about D8

  • I do not think the D8 development architecture will change anymore (therefor it's too late).
  • So to start developing with D8 with a production date far away from today might make sense. And if you adapt to the new (OOP) stuff with Symphony, etc, then you probably don't need many more changes by the time D8 gets released.
  • Be careful however with an assumption like "... D8 is just about ready". Even if there are only a seven critical issues left before RC1.
  • D8's first beta was released at DrupalCon A'dam (2014). And I wouldn't be surprised if somewhere between Sept 17, 2015 and Sept 24, 2015 the first RC1 would be released (at DrupalCon Barcelona). But from then on an official release will not be just a matter of weeks (I "hope" for somewhere in 2016 ... and would "love" it to be in "2015" still).
  • The key challenge after D8 is released will be the contrib modules you'd need: if you can get the job done with hardly any contrib modules (now that Views is in core), then you're fine. But what if you'd depend on modules that only support D7? Or modules that don't have a stable D8 release yet, such as the Rules module?

Future-Proof your Drupal 7 site

To make transitioning to Drupal 8 easier, there are quite some decisions can you make now on your current or new Drupal 7 sites.

For more details on that, refer to the (amazing I think) presentation of David Reid about all those amazing contributed modules in Drupal 7, which are like backports of new Drupal 8 features.

  • Pierre, Do you think the D8 development architecture will change? I don't have to have it today. But, I would like to start developing. If D8 is going to change a bunch so that my modules or whatever are no good, then I have to wait. I hate to use 7 if 8 is just about ready. I saw there are only seven critical things left before RC1.
    – johnny
    Aug 31, 2015 at 16:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.