4

At the risk of asking a "too open ended question" I'm giving it a try:

I'm running into more and more situations where I have to decide to either use a module that does a lot more than what I need or just writing my own code or template mod.

For example, the password policy has features that I need, but also has a lot that I don't. The 47kb zip file size tells me that it's a lot of code for my small problem. I implemented my own password policy with less than 20 lines of code in a hook.

I'm trying to limit the total amount of modules installed to a max of around 100. However, since signups don't happen that frequently this module probably won't affect the overall site performance.

Does anyone have specific recommendations on when to use a module vs. writing own code? Especially when better runtime performance and reduced overall complexity are the main goals.

4

The way I go about deciding whether to use a module or write my own code is roughly the following:

  1. If the functionality I need can be written with a couple of lines of code I don't even start looking for a module to do it. Using a module for every little thing often gets you a good portion of extra code and other data that you don't need. All the unnecessary extras could:

    • negatively affect performance
    • make the site more complex and harder to maintain
    • result in more bugs
  2. If there would be a considerable amount of code to write I'll look for possibly existing modules to make the task easier. Good reasons to use a existing module in my book:

    • it fits the requirements fairly well: using the module (and altering it with hooks, adding extra functionality via a custom module where needed) to get exactly what's needed is easier/faster than writing everything from scratch.
    • the site administrator needs to be able to change specific settings via the GUI and the module already offers that.
1
  • Excellent answer. This is pretty much my approach to whether or not to use a contributed module. – drmonkeyninja Feb 27 '12 at 13:17
0

One of solution is to write your global module which will contain all your little bundles of custom code.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.