I've blocked the IP address at admin/config/people/ip-blocking and I can see it also in the flood control logs as a blocked IP, but the IP is still accessing the site and I can see errors in the watchdog with their IP address after the block...
I'm at a complete loss as to how this could be... google and SE search has brought nothing. Why isn't Drupal blocking this IP?
Edit: I tested it with a firend's IP and it's not blocking him either, so I guess my IP blocking is not working at all...