Are there any modules or installation profiles available to create a peer-review system, such as used by academic journals and conferences? I've found lots of discussions on Drupal.org but no actively maintained modules.

Update: here is an example of a commercial system showing the kinds of features I'm looking for.

  • Could you give a non-Drupal example that shows the kind of things you are after? – Chapabu Apr 3 '12 at 13:18
  • @chapabu pls see update for an example. this is just the first one I found that shows off features with some level of detail. I am not implying that that system is in any way ideal. – ted.strauss Apr 3 '12 at 15:12

Depending on what you would like to do, there are two potential approaches.

On the simple end, you have fields on content types that only certain roles can edit. For example, you can have a field called vetted and two roles, author and expert. When an author makes a new node, vetted would get set to some default value, like not verified. Your expert users can then read and review the nodes, and sets the vetted field as appropriate, say verified or needs further review.

One the more complex end, you can use workflow. Two modules that do this are Workflow and Workbench. With this, you can set up just about any editorial review process that you want. Both can also be combined with Drupal actions to occur on state transitions. Just keep in mind that workflow can be a pain to set up, and often there are real work scenarios that don't always work into rigid workflow rules.

As for existing systems, Open Atrium may potentially fit the bill. It is more designed for team collaboration, but based on what clients have said, it may work for something more conference oriented.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.